So you’re writing a novel and it’s a heartbreaking work of staggering genius, except that all your characters talk alike. What can you do to avoid that pesky sameness in your dialogue?
Tim posted this question on my “Ask A Question For My Blog” page:
I have a issue with having my characters sound a like. I have great details on each of their personalities but other one secondary character they all seem the Sam. One is the dialogue, how do I make the sound different?
Randy sez: That’s a great question, Tim. It’s a question every novelist faces.
Let’s try to understand first WHY all your characters are sounding alike in their dialogue.
The reason is because all your characters inherit quite a bit of their personality from you. That is necessarily true. Your characters aren’t real. They spring out of your imagination. They exist because you thought them into existence.
Which means they are limited by you and your experiences. If you’re an American and have never met any Germans, it would be really hard for you to write a German character. If you’re a southerner and have never met any yankees, then you’ll have a hard time writing a yankee character.
So the solution to getting rid of the sameness in your dialogue come in two steps:
- Meet more people.
- Steal their voices.
Let’s look at each of those in a little more detail.
Meet More People
When I say you need to meet more people, I mean people who are different from you. Wildly different. One of the best things I ever did for my writing career was to spend six years at UC Berkeley working on my Ph.D. in physics.
While I was at Berkeley, I met an amazing assortment of people. Panhandlers. Nobel laureates. Religious nuts. Political fanatics on the far right and far left.
My classmates came from all across the US and all around the world. I spent a lot of time with people from China, India, Korea, eastern Europe.
One of my close friends was an 80-year-old woman. Another had cerebral palsy. I had friends getting degrees in history, English literature, engineering. And I was a teaching assistant for a while and wound up trying to explain physics to a lot of normal people who don’t speak math.
I’m an introvert, but in my time at Berkeley, I got a serious education in the enormous differences in how people think. Which comes out in the way they talk.
Steal Their Voices
This has been immensely valuable to me in my fiction writing, because I had a huge number of people whose voices I could steal.
In one of my novels, I needed a cranky old midwife. No problem. One of my best friends at Berkeley was an 80-year-old woman who always said exactly what she was thinking. She didn’t have an internal censor. So when I was writing dialogue for my cranky midwife, I just asked myself how my friend would say it. I’d actually hear her voice in my head and then I’d just write down what she said.
In another book, I had a minor character who was an exuberant extroverted Israeli archaeologist. He spoke English with the same charming accent as my tour guide when I visited Israel. I remember listening to that guide and memorizing the sound of his voice because I knew I was going to put him in a book someday.
Whenever I have a character who’s very different from me, I ask myself what real person I’ve known who was like that character. Then I try to imagine having a conversation with that real person, and listen to their voice. What pet words do they overuse? What slang do they use? How do they think about the world?
Don’t Copy Too Exactly
One thing you want to avoid is trying to reproduce a person’s accent too exactly. If you’ve ever read GONE WITH THE WIND, you probably struggled to understand the way-too-literal reproduction of the speech patterns of slaves from the Civil War era. Every word is misspelled the way it sounds, making it almost unreadable for modern readers. In cases like this, spell the words correctly but misuse the grammar the way the speaker actually says it. That strikes a balance that your reader can understand.
Different people tend to use different thought patterns. Try to capture those as exactly as you can. If you have a character who isn’t very original, he might use a lot of cliches when he talks.
One thing to be wary of is capturing the exact slang-of-the-moment. That might work for a year or two, but slang tends to go out of style pretty quickly and then it sounds dated. So if you’re going to use slang, make it up. Then it can never go out of style.
Tim, I hope that answers your question. You get better at writing dialogue by writing a lot of dialogue. You get better at writing in different voices by writing in different voices.
Here’s an exercise to force you to build your dialogue muscles: Write an entire scene in dialogue without using any tags to identify the characters. This means you can’t use “Joe said” or “Mary said” anywhere in the scene. And you can’t even use action tags, such as “Voldemort slammed his fist on the table.”
You have to write the whole scene in what I call “naked dialogue”–just the dialogue, without action or description or interior monologue or interior emotion or narrative summary or exposition.
It’s hard to do, but it forces you to learn the tricks that help distinguish between your characters’ voices.
You will rarely use naked dialogue in an actual scene of a book, but writing it as an exercise will build your skills in dialogue fast.
If you’ve got a question you’d like me to answer in public on this blog, hop on over to my “Ask A Question For My Blog” page and submit your question. I’ll answer them in the order they come in.
This helps answer my question somewhat. My characters have great details profiles and personalities. Since most of my writings are first drafts I don’t care if they sound a like, but I am going to have really think when I write my characters speech. I like how you said how would your friend say it. I think that will work, and the naked dialogue exercise will help as well.
Thanks for answering my question.
Elizabeth Kitchens says
Great post, Randy. I really like your “naked dialogue” suggestion. Podcasts are a great (and easy) way to learn voices. I listen to This Week in Microbiology, This Week in Virology, Novel Marketing, and Michael Hyatt’s podcast. I love the voices and the interplay of the hosts as much as the content.
Robyn LaRue says
Good points, and I know the exercises work. It might help some writers to speak dialogue out loud or even recruit a friend to read with you. And I have a new tip to try.(podcasts). Thanks!
Dialogue and the tone of voice can be a tough balancing act between characters. I love listening to the tone and fall of peoples voices to get ideas to use. Podcasts are a great idea for variety. I tend to sit back imagine a recent conversation and then have those people talk about the subject I’m writing, it works well.
I recently had a problem where one of my characters seemed to talk with the tone and style of a friend of mine, I didn’t want this because I knew that it wasn’t consistent with his real character. I then did an exercise where I wrote him having a conversation from the personal “I” point of view; he certainly changed his tone and began to speak more like the person I wanted him to be just because his ideas were coming with more urgency and honesty.